Senator Nicole Mitchell Convicted of Felony Burglary
A Detroit Lakes jury has found Minnesota state Senator Nicole Mitchell guilty of felony burglary. The verdict, delivered just hours after closing arguments, included charges of first-degree burglary and possession of burglary tools. This conviction carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison, marking a significant legal consequence for the DFL-Woodbury representative.
Political Implications
The outcome of the trial could have far-reaching effects on the balance of power at the Minnesota State Capitol. Democrats currently hold a one-seat majority in the Senate, and Mitchell’s conviction may challenge that stability. As a first-term Democrat, Mitchell is also a meteorologist and former lieutenant colonel in the Air National Guard. Since her arrest on April 22, 2024, following a burglary report at her stepmother’s home in Detroit Lakes, she has faced mounting pressure to resign.
Details of the Incident
Mitchell was discovered in the basement of her stepmother’s home wearing black clothing. At the time, she told officers that she was there to retrieve her late father’s belongings. However, she later denied any intent to steal, claiming she was trying to check on her stepmother due to concerns about Alzheimer’s and related paranoia. During her trial, Mitchell admitted to trespassing in the home and acknowledged lying to police about her reasons for being there. She explained that her actions were motivated by concern for her ailing stepmother.
Legal Arguments
Mitchell’s defense attorney emphasized the distinction between trespassing and burglary during closing arguments, suggesting that the state could not rule out the possibility that Mitchell entered the home simply to check on her stepmother. In contrast, prosecutors argued that Mitchell’s explanations lacked credibility. They highlighted the tools she brought with her, including latex gloves and a small crowbar, questioning the necessity of such items. “Who packs a freaking prybar just in case?” asked Becker County Attorney Brian McDonald during his closing argument.
Political Reactions
Mitchell has repeatedly resisted calls from Republicans to resign following her arrest. While some top Democrats, including Governor Tim Walz, have expressed the belief that she should step down, the Senate DFL Caucus has consistently blocked Republican efforts to remove her from her seat. Defenders of Mitchell within the Legislature, including Senate Majority Leader Erin Murphy, acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations but emphasized her right to due process.
Legislative Influence
As a result, Mitchell was able to continue casting what amounted to the deciding vote whenever the narrowly divided chamber split along party lines. These votes included major pieces of the DFL’s agenda during the 2024 session, covering budget-related bills, procedural fights, and resolutions concerning her own position in the Senate.
Next Steps
Following the verdict, Murphy stated that Mitchell had indicated her intention to resign if found guilty of the crime and expected her to follow through. The governor’s office also mentioned that Walz anticipates Mitchell will resign and plans to provide more information about a special election soon.
Potential Consequences
The Minnesota Legislature is scheduled to reconvene in February. If Mitchell does not resign, Governor Walz could call a special session to consider an expulsion vote. A two-thirds majority would be required to forcibly remove her from the chamber. The next steps in this situation will be closely watched by political observers and constituents alike.
