Understanding the Evolution of Eyeliner Techniques for Mature Eyes
Eyeliner is a powerful tool that can define, lengthen, and open up the eyes, adding a touch of drama or subtle sophistication. However, as we age, the delicate skin around our eyes undergoes changes – it can become thinner, lose elasticity, and develop fine lines or crepiness. What worked perfectly in our 20s or 30s might inadvertently have the opposite effect in our 50s and beyond, drawing unwanted attention to areas we’d prefer to softly enhance.
“The goal of eyeliner on mature eyes isn’t to replicate youthful techniques, but to adapt and refine them to flatter the eye’s changing contours,” explains Dr. Sarah Jenkins, a celebrity makeup artist and mature beauty specialist. “Some common practices can actually drag the eye down, settle into lines, or create a heavy, aging effect. It’s about working with your skin, not against it.”
By understanding which techniques to avoid, you can ensure your eyeliner always enhances, rather than detracts from, your beautiful, expressive eyes. Here are 7 eyeliner techniques professional makeup artists advise avoiding if you have older eyes:
1. Heavy Liquid Liner All Around the Eye
Why to Avoid: A thick, unbroken line of liquid liner around the entire eye can look harsh and “close off” the eyes, making them appear smaller. On mature skin, liquid liner can also crack or settle into fine lines, highlighting texture.
Instead: Focus on the upper lash line only. If you use liquid, opt for a thin, precise line just at the base of the lashes. Consider a softer pencil or gel liner for a less stark effect, especially on the lower lash line.
2. Lining the Inner Waterline with Black Kohl
Why to Avoid: Lining the inner lower waterline with dark black kohl can make the eyes look smaller and can transfer easily, creating smudges or dark circles beneath the eyes throughout the day.
Instead: If you want to line the lower waterline, opt for a nude or white pencil to make the eyes appear brighter and more open. For a subtle definition, tightline the upper waterline to make lashes look thicker without adding visible liner.
3. Drawing a Sharp, Angular Wing (Especially Pointing Downward)
Why to Avoid: A super sharp, upward-flicked wing can sometimes look disconnected on mature eyes, especially if there’s hooding or crepiness at the outer corner. A downward-sloping wing can visually pull the eye down.
Instead: Aim for a softer, more lifted “kitten flick” or a very gentle, upward-angled wing that follows the natural upward curve of your lower lash line. Use a gel or pencil liner and smudge it slightly for a softer, more blended look.
4. Applying Liner Too Far Down on the Lower Lash Line
Why to Avoid: Extending eyeliner too far down from the lower lash line (like a heavy smudge or a line beneath the lashes) can create the illusion of dark circles or bags, making eyes appear tired and older.
Instead: Stick to lining only the outer third of the lower lash line, and smudge it very softly with a brush to create a subtle shadow rather than a harsh line. Use a lighter, softer shade like brown or charcoal instead of black.
5. Using Dry, Tuggy Pencils
Why to Avoid: Old, dry, or hard eyeliner pencils require you to pull and tug at the delicate eye area, which can damage elasticity over time and create an uneven, patchy line.
Instead: Invest in creamy, smooth-gliding pencil or gel liners. They apply effortlessly without dragging and allow for easier blending.
6. Skipping Eyelash Curling
Why to Avoid: As we age, lashes can thin and lose their natural curl. Straight lashes, even with eyeliner, can make eyes look less open.
Instead: Always curl your lashes before applying mascara. This simple step instantly lifts and opens the eyes, making them appear larger and more awake, allowing your eyeliner to truly shine.
7. Overdoing Eyeliner on Hooded Eyes
Why to Avoid: With hooded eyes (where a fold of skin covers the crease), applying too much or too thick a line of eyeliner can disappear into the hood or make the lid space look even smaller and heavier.
Instead: Focus on tightlining the upper lash line (applying liner directly into the lash roots) and extending a very thin, precise line just slightly above the lash line. This defines the eyes without overwhelming them. A “winged” look on hooded eyes often requires a specific technique (drawing the wing with the eye open to find the correct angle).
By being mindful of these common missteps, you can refine your eyeliner technique to beautifully enhance your eyes, celebrating their wisdom and expressive charm without inadvertently aging your look.
